“There’s only one way this ends. Last man standing.”
The hard-hitting, nerve-killing technical achievement that is 1917 is now in theaters, and it offers a look at the trench warfare from WWI in an all too realistic ride. Make sure to pack your anti-anxiety medication for this one, because 1917 will have you white- knuckling, teeth grinding for 110 solid minutes.
Don’t listen to critics saying this movie is too “boring” to be considered great, memorable, or even a best picture Oscar winner. They’re over-analytical snobs, and I’ll tell you now how wrong they are.
1917 may not be the greatest war movie of all time (note: do NOT think nor try to go into this comparing it to a WWI Saving Private Ryan), but it’s certainly the best at depicting WWI trench warfare. If my recommendation doesn’t persuade you enough to watch it (if you haven’t), then you should know that it’s nominated for Best Picture at this year’s Academy Awards. Currently, 1917’s odds on winning that category is +240, trailing slightly behind Once Upon A Time In Hollywood.
The premise is two young (teenagers y’all!) British soldiers during WWI are given an impossible mission: deliver a message deep in enemy territory that will stop 1,600 men, including one of the soldiers’ brothers, from walking into a deadly trap.
It’s very much a ‘learn from the past so you don’t make those same mistakes’ movie as described by director and writer Sam Mendes (American Beauty!!). The story is also a direct inspiration from Mendes’s grandfather who served from 1916 to 1918.
It shouldn’t go without mention that this movie is a great balance between war as well as humanity. Yet, some critics missed the point of this darkly gripping experience entirely citing the movie as a hollow, missed opportunity. Someone even took it as far to say it felt like a series of Call of Duty cut scenes, a video game with no control. Lol, okay. Let’s explain.
1917 is a massive technical achievement done right…special shout out to cinematographer Roger Deakins for this one. The camera tracks these two soldiers with a smooth one continuous shot for 110 minutes (read: the camera never stops…sort of), and it’s totally brilliant.
The movie borrows its hidden cuts from a technique first seen in Alfred Hitchcock’s Rope (1948). Like that film, Sam Mendes would move the camera behind an object during a scene, such as a tree or burnt out building where the camera could be stopped then restarted without a noticeable edit.
Why was it important to film as a single shot? According to Mendes, you’re not given much background to these two characters, so the one shot technique gives you their step- by-step experience on this mission. Literally. It’s one of the realest and rawest experiences I’ve had in a theater in a very long time.
Is this the best movie of 2019? It depends on who you’re talking to, and how one merits a movie as the best. This is certainly in close competition for me with Jojo Rabbit, but while both movies showcase the horrors of war, they’re achievements in their own rights.
13 thoughts on “Is 1917 the Best Movie of 2019?”
It’s crazy that people would call this boring, when did it slow down enough for someone to think that? lol
I really liked this. It didn’t quite make my Top 10 but it was close.
Ooo did you post your top 10??? I’ll go check 😀
Nice review! This is one of the final films I have to catch up with for the Oscars, and I’m holding out to hopefully catch it in theaters. It looks absolutely incredible.
Thanks, Katy! Def watch it on the big screen!
Thank you for keeping the review spoiler free! It definitely increased my desire to see the movie.
I’m glad!! Thanks, Sara!!
Great review of a great movie. It really gives you so much to talk about and admire. I’m so anxious to see it again.
Thanks, Keith! I wanna see it again too!
This is such a daring venture – close to 2 hours of a single shot (granted with the magic of editing). I’m really looking forward to seeing this.
It’s pretty genius. Thanks for reading, Jade!!
I loved it, but not as much as Dunkirk. That said, it’s a shame MacKay is not getting nominations for his work
I agree…I prefer Dunkirk more too. Love Mackay 💝
I liked this one a lot. I’m still trying to gather my thoughts for a review, this made me very emotional. I also, and let’s get this out of the way, liked it a lot more than Jojo Rabbit.
1917 for me did feel a bit like a computer game but that’s not a bad thing. Games are popular for a reason, they immerse you into the world of the game and 1917 just pulls you right in. There were many shorts in there that I thought “WOW” and wanted to screen capture the damn thing.
For me, this is almost the best of 2019.